patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

The Mean Streets Of Columbia? Talking to My Kids About Race, Class, Crime

My kids must know our neighborhood's not a ghetto.

 

“Some guy got arrested on our street today,” volunteered the 13-year-old when I got home. “There were like, five cop cars.”

“Crummy ghetto neighborhood,” added his 11-year-old brother.

My family lives in an older townhouse community near the Owen Brown Village Center. Our neighborhood is populated by government employees, scientists, HVAC technicians, and people with housing vouchers—residents from all over the world and from around the way. There are always kids playing in the cul-de-sac and people working on their lawns.

Aaaaaand there are regular visits by the police, and young men hanging out smoking marijuana outside one of the end units, and cars that pull up for five or 10 minutes at all hours of the day and then screech away.

My kids' school, Cradlerock, has terrific teachers and great Gifted and Talented classes. It also has some of the lowest test scores and highest percentage of kids receiving free breakfast and lunch in Columbia.

“This is one of the richest counties in the whole country,” I sputter at my little ingrates. “And Columbia was founded on the principle of racial integration. A ghetto is a place where people are forced to live on the basis of race or religion.”

 I remember moving here in high school 20-some years ago from an economically depressed and racially polarized town in Michigan. I was blown away by the sheer wealth of this place and the degree of racial integration.

Twenty-some years later, I can see that Columbia has its own poverty and racial fault lines lurking beneath the Benetton-ad exterior. But when my kids throw out the word “ghetto,” it ticks me off.

It reminds me that Columbia is the only reality they know.

I tell them, “A lot of people who don't know what 'ghetto' really means think it means 'poor and black.' If you call our neighborhood a ghetto, people will think it's because a lot of our neighbors are black. Then you sound like a racist. And it's not like the white people around here aren't getting arrested or selling dope as much as anyone else.”

My kids will grow up with their own preferences and prejudices, that's inevitable. I don't care about teaching them to be “politically correct.”

I just never want to hear them claim they didn't know a word or phrase might be offensive to people from an ethnic or religious background different from ours.

If we let them throw around words like “ghetto” without at least making sure they know the history and unspoken implications behind the word, we wouldn't be doing our job as parents.

So the word “ghetto” doesn't pass unchallenged when my kids use it.

When the cops show up two or three times in one week instead of their usual once a month, however, the word “slum” springs to mind. But I'll wait for them to come up with that one on their own.

About this column: Kate Yemelyanov has three children – two sons, 14 and 11, and one daughter, 9 – plus a full-time job with one heck of a commute. She and her family live in Columbia in Owen Brown. "Mom On The Run" appears monthly on Columbia Patch. And you can also follow her at http://www.twitter.com/dinosaurmom or check out her blog, "Dinosaur Mom Chronicles," at http://www.dinosaurmom.com

Courtney

11:51 am on Monday, May 16, 2011

"And it's not like the white people around here aren't getting arrested or selling dope as much as anyone else."

If only that were actually true.

Reply

Gert

2:09 pm on Monday, May 16, 2011

"Aaaaaand there are regular visits by the police, and young men hanging out smoking marijuana outside one of the end units, and cars that pull up for five or 10 minutes at all hours of the day and then screech away."

Do you really want your children to grow up thinking that's the norm in the world? I live in Howard County but I don't have regular visits by the police or drug issues. Sounds like you are defending living in a relatively dangerous neighborhood.

Reply

Kate Yemelyanov

2:43 pm on Monday, May 16, 2011

Courtney, I can't speak to the demographics of arrest or drug trafficking in Columbia writ large, but my neighborhood dealers are predominately white. Their partners and clientele are a mix of ethnicities. The last few people arrested here were also white.

Gert, my point isn't that I think it's great to share my neighborhood with dope dealers. My point is that the presence of petty crime here and poverty there doth not a ghetto make. I want my kids to grow up understanding the difference between a neighborhood like ours, which has problems but also has a lot decent people and amenities, and a place where people are isolated by poverty and prejudice. I don't consider this a dangerous place. And drugs are everywhere in Howard County, not just in places where the dealers conveniently make themselves visible.

Reply

Kate Yemelyanov

10:43 pm on Monday, May 16, 2011

Mark, my neighbors (and I, though not as often as I should) do precisely that - cleaning up, demanding respect for where our kids play, just being outside. It makes a huge difference.

I don't think we have a "ghetto tidal wave," though. I think we have a dwindling pool of affordable housing stock in the region, a lot people struggling to make ends meet, and a broader community that has too much of its identity vested in being affluent to devote resources to meeting the needs of its poorer residents. My neighborhood library is flooded every afternoon with kids who don't have any place to be after school. The upper school at Cradlerock (soon to be Lake Elkhorn Middle) has no afterschool sports teams or clubs that might occupy the time and attention of kids whose parents don't have money and time to chauffeur them to lessons and private league teams. If we don't want our town's run-down neighborhoods to turn into real ghettos, these are issues Columbia and Howard County need to address.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mark

1:44 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Kate,

That must be you picking up the trash on days I don't, thanks! I've cut back to only doing it on trash night instead of every night, so the middle of the week is the worst. Won't argue about the Hokusai reference--maybe tidal wave was a little bit of hyperbole. Of course there are economic causes at the root. The social remedies are many. I'll return to coaching soon, so the often vacant fields we know so well are used more often. That's something I've done for almost twenty years, and right now my wife and I are focused on our youngest who is pre-team sports age and our high schooler. Yeah, that's real...I volunteer coach when it means I can spend more time with my children. As for coaching other kids' teams and activities, I do that when I'm not coaching my own but when I'm still active with their teams. 'Columbia and Howard County' are 'us.' Those who model 'urban flight' behaviors will always do so. As long as poverty and violence exist as a way of life in communities the whole world is a ghetto. No mansion, no plane, no walls, no amount of acerage or mobility can keep the ills of poverty and violence from affecting each of us as long as they are a way of life either chosen by or inflicted on people. I hear you, Gert. Getting tired is real and we'll end up moving eventually. For us, it's just about building strong relationships wherever we are and I see that Kate and many others understand that begins with ourselves and then with our children.

Gert

11:26 am on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

We lived in Hickory Ridge and had many of the same issues that you are experiencing. Drugs, fights, etc. When there was a murder in Wilde Lake, they came to our neighborhood looking for the suspect. We were not apathetic, but, when you said something to people tossing trash, using language inappropriate for the little ones playing outside, etc., you were pretty well guaranteed to have your tires slashed, fence broken, house robbed, etc. Call the police you say, well, they either wouldn't come or would do a drive through and that was it. Eventually, folks not involved in these behaviors have moved. You just get tired of picking up other people's trash, getting contact highs when you go to your car and ignoring everybody else's behavior.

Reply

Jen Raffensperger

12:02 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Thanks for sharing this, Kate, and for talking to your kids about it. When I moved to Columbia (and Howard County) seven years ago, I remember an evening early on when I tried to order a pizza. "Oh," the pizza place told me on the phone, "We don't deliver to that neighborhood after dark." I had only lived in my Stevens Forest Road apartment a month or so at that point, but I am afraid I laughed out loud at that. Compared to so many places even very, very close by, so much of Columbia is a bit of a wonderland.

That is not to say that it's okay that we rough it up a bit, but I think you are onto something in that there are some teaching moments here for young people, especially young people who have had the great good fortune to grow up in our very affluent community.

Reply

Corey Andrews

4:10 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Maybe Columbia isn't technically not a "ghetto", but it is a poor, run-down, dirty, drug-infested, failed planned community with residents who are snobby when they have ZERO reason to be. I actually prefer to avoid Columbia in my travels. Just because it was nice 20 years ago, doesn't mean it is now, and it would take serious reforms to make it even comparable to the rest of the county. Everyone used to talk bad about my town, Elkridge, the place with the strongest sense of community in the county, and now everyone seems to want to move here or to western Howard County.

Reply
Comment_arrow

David Greisman

4:28 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Where outside of Howard County have you lived, Corey?

Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

5:59 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

I haven't. I love where I live now.

Comment_arrow

Andrew Kanicki

12:01 am on Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Corey, you are in high school are you not? When you have lived outside of the "HoCo Bubble" for sometime, then lets talk. I have lived in five different cities all over the county.Trust me when I tell you, Columbia is NOT a ghetto or a slum. Actually, it has become my favorite places. Does it have its issues? Absolutely. What city doesn't? Put things into persepective. Columbia has a population of nearly 100,000. Not everyone is going to be white and making $200k a year. When I was relocated here for my partner's job, I looked at houses in Elkridge & Ellicott City. I passed. While there are many lovely areas of those two towns, none of them offered the ammenities and sense of neighborhood that columbia offered. I am so sure that those fantastic and upscale "mobile home" neighborhoods of Elkridge are completely crime free and feature a Volvo in every driveway. No drugs or prostitution along Route 1, its a veritable country club down there! Columbia is "poor"? I think not. Just look at the average income of Columbia! "Snobby"? Possibly, but maybe you are mistaking pride for snobbery. I'm 30 years old, and am a very succesful Real Estate proefssional. My partner is an executive for a Fortune 50 retailer, hardly the type to live in a "ghetto".I've read your posts on numerous HoCo blogs, and I must tell you, that you should stop trying to sound intelligent and informed, and concentrate on something that you are good at.

Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

12:38 pm on Saturday, February 11, 2012

I have to point out that this comment was not made by me, a candidate for the Board of Ed. If you look at the account that the above comment was made under, you will see that it is not the account I usually use to comment on Patch(this one). It is, most likely, someone on the Howardpubliced weblist that knew I was going to run for the board of ed and wanted to prank me or tear me down. I would never make such comments about a community I wish to represent.

Opinionfountain

6:27 pm on Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Corey, your put-downs offend me. My neighborhood is NONE of those!!! It's pretty, average-wage, clean, no drug activity noticable (within 1/2 mile), and healthy, definitely NOT failed.

And yet, snobs like you call my neighborhood a ghetto.

Check out the race & class statistics - I saw a correlation between neighborhoods that are integrated and middle-income and those that are unfairly being called ghettos, primarily by the kids from nearly-all-white, rich neighborhoods.

Reply

Kate Yemelyanov

9:46 am on Thursday, May 19, 2011

My problem as a parent is that my Columbia babies, who live in our integrated and middle-income neighborhood, are the ones calling it a ghetto. My husband, who's never lived anywhere in the US except Columbia, shares Corey's assessment. I don't agree with them (except about the "snobby" part, but I have that complaint about the greater DC metro area in general).

Reply

Katy Clemens

12:06 pm on Tuesday, September 27, 2011

kate, i think you and i are kindred spirits. thank you for this. i live over off of carved stone, not far from minstrel way, which has its share of robberies. we do have a neighborhood drug dealer. we also have kids who play all over the neighborhood every day, including my own son. many of the adults are out chit-chatting too. it's a friendly place, the houses are beautiful, and i love it here. i grew up out in carroll county, and i moved my family to howard county (after living in salt lake city, new york, city, and takoma park) for good schools, lovely neighborhoods, and racial and socioeconomic diversity. i didn't understand the racial aspects of the world i lived in until i got out of carroll county and went to umbc.

i have a neighbor who sends her kids to private school because too many kids who need free and reduced lunch go to talbott springs. personally, i don't automatically think that something is wrong with poor kids. i think my kid will learn from all the kids he meets. i'm glad we live here.

Reply

Polly

12:01 pm on Wednesday, September 28, 2011

I know this is late BUT I just had to comment on something Andrew Kanicki said that has my blood boiling! I spent most of my 50+ years of living in PG County and moved to Howard County about 5 years ago, Jessup in particular. I moved to HoCo at the recommendation of many of my friends that have moved here over the past 10 years. I myself didn't know much about HoCo but have learned a lot and love living here. Due to a serious back disability I had to live on one level and did not want to be in an apartment/condo, been there done that. Plus I'd owned my own home and wanted some space and peace. My home sold quickly and I didn't have the luxury of time to find another home to buy. Due to the lack of knowledge on my part I bought a mobile home located in a park. It happens to be so much nicer than you could ever believe. It's clean, well kept and safe. Neighbors take great pride in maintaining their homes and yards. Every single person that has come to my home has been pleasantly surprised at how wonderful it is here. I feel very safe here and can't think of a single incident causing the police to come. I have one neighbor that owns a big beautiful boat even. Many of my neighbors are professionals that have many housing options available to them, but they choose to live here. Your uneducated, misinformed, malicious comment about mobile home parks reflects your ignorance. I am offended. Its getting harder for me to maintain this place, perhaps you might want to buy it? Never mind

Reply
Comment_arrow

Andrew Kanicki

10:18 am on Monday, February 13, 2012

Polly, I'm glad that you "love where you live", as we all should. Good luck with that, and Ill pass on your offer to buy your home.

kyle

5:07 pm on Saturday, February 11, 2012

Corey we all know you are full of BS. You made similar comments on explore howard last year and caused a huge firestorm and got called out.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

6:11 pm on Saturday, February 11, 2012

I have personally never made any comments defaming Columbia. I do often point out that the ARE communities that are under-represented, and I guess some people would like to use that against by posting things that would look as though I posted them. If I did actually make these comments, why would I bring attention to them by commenting on this article? I want people to know that I did not say these things. If you don't believe that, I'm sorry.

Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

6:18 pm on Saturday, February 11, 2012

Also, note the fact that, if they were my comments, I would have been able to delete them.

Brook Hubbard

5:34 pm on Saturday, February 11, 2012

On the one hand, I have to concur that Columbia is not a ghetto. It has some bad patches, but overall it is a decent community. Whoever thinks Columbia is a ghetto obviously has not lived elsewhere. I grew up in PG County; I attended school in Glenarden, Landover, and Forestville; I worked in Riverdale, Bladensburg, and Clinton. Howard County is a hundred times better than anything I ever had to deal with on a regular basis.

However... that doesn't mean Howard County can't be "ghetto" or that it is appropriate. I'm not using the term "ghetto" to mean poor, African-American... I'm using the term I grew up with on the streets of PG, to mean trashy, crime-filled, and with an attitude. There are neighborhoods, or even specific streets in nicer areas, where that ghetto 'tude is rampant. Groups of teenagers and 20-somethings hanging out and shooting nasty looks at passers-by. Drug use and dealing, both subtle and not quite so. Assault and robberies, theft and burglary, etc. I know these things quiet well, because I used to be involved with aspects of this side of things.

Columbia is not a "ghetto" and I'm glad I'm raising my children here. However, it is not the safe utopia everyone makes it out to be and my children shouldn't have to experience even a modicum of what I dealt with when I was their age.

Reply

Julia McCready

3:45 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

@Corey--as you WERE able to delete your comment suggesting Robert Rhodes was stealing from the school system since he disagreed with you?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

5:28 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

Yes, I was. And, with his request, I did.

Let's set something straight. He was not disagreeing with me... he was insulting me.

Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

8:36 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

I will add that the topic of this going on among the members of Howardpubliced had been discussed for a while. There was cause to believe that some suspicious activity was going on.

kyle

8:50 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

So Corey do you still think that Columbia is a "poor, run down, drug infested, failed planned community..." ??? Hey if you do thats ok. We don't like you either.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

9:01 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

I'm pretty sure I addressed that. Those comments were made from a fraudulent account. Click on my account name and search through all of the posts. Those do not appear as my comments. If those were my comments, why would I have not deleted them by now?

Comment_arrow

Corey Andrews

9:05 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

Plus, it wouldn't even make sense to say. I spend much of my time in Columbia Town Center, and I love it there. Why would I say such things about a place I want to represent? There are a few people(probably just one) on the Howardpubliced listserv who have done this to me before... created fraudulent accounts on forums and websites. They know I advocate for Elkridge, so they use that against me to look like I hate some place else.

Comment_arrow

H.R. Pufnstuf

9:20 pm on Sunday, March 4, 2012

"The problem with quotes on the internet is that it's hard to determine if they are real or not." - Abraham Lincoln

Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

5:29 pm on Saturday, June 2, 2012

I have deleted several comments that contained profanity and were considered obscene. Please review the Patch terms of use here: http://oldtownalexandria.patch.com/terms

Reply

Leave a comment