Miscarriages, Blame and the Baby I Love
A miscarriage from a couple years ago weighed on my mind while I was pregnant with my son, and is a memory I still carry with me.
About two years ago this summer, I had a miscarriage.
It’s a topic that many women don’t like to admit or talk about.
No matter how much progress we’ve made as a society, there are still implications that if a woman gets pregnant and loses her baby, it’s her fault.
About 15 to 20 percent of known pregnancies end in miscarriage (the loss of pregnancy before the 20th week), but according to the Mayo Clinic the number is likely much higher, with many occurring before a woman even knows she’s pregnant.
Nationally, conversations continue about whether women are to blame for their miscarriages.
A recent law passed in Utah holds women criminally liable for illegal abortions. Abortion rights advocates have said they worry it could criminalize a woman’s behavior during pregnancy.
Earlier versions of the law referred to the “reckless behavior” of a woman, and some feared that it could lead to a woman being persecuted for having a miscarriage, according to AOLnews.com.
In my case, doctors assured me I wasn’t to blame for my miscarriage. But after it happened, I made a mental list of things I did that could have caused it.
Perhaps it was the coffee I couldn’t give up.
Maybe it was the drink or two I had before I found out I was pregnant.
I even thought perhaps there was something strange and spiritual about it, and my husband and I just weren’t mature enough yet to handle a new baby. (But I realize now: Is anyone ever truly ready for parenthood?)
None of these things caused the miscarriage, but I thought them anyway.
My doctors assured me that it is simply a biological fluke. In a few words: It just happens.
During my second pregnancy—the one that resulted in my now nearly 5-month-old son, Gabe—I heard many messages about how anything I did could harm him.
A yoga teacher once told me I was selfish for continuing an upbeat fitness routine in my first trimester. She said that I needed to realign my priorities and make my life about my baby, not myself.
I heard concerns from people when they learned that I continued to pet and cuddle with my cats. (Doctors say a pregnant woman shouldn’t do litter box duties, but she can continue to enjoy her pets.)
Even so, I tried my best to relax and enjoy my second pregnancy and not spend the entire time worrying that I would suffer a loss again.
My husband and I took long walks. We traveled. We spent time with friends.
I enjoyed a cup of coffee every morning. We even went to an Avett Brothers concert in Baltimore when I was eight months along.
But that doesn’t mean I wasn’t still haunted by what happened.
In the month before Gabe was born, I would sometimes wake up in the middle of the night with worries that something would go wrong with the birth.
I think I decided to have a natural birth partly so I could control the whole thing.
There is a picture in our family photo album of me looking up at my husband moments after the birth, which was long and painful—but in the end, very satisfying.
There were tears in my eyes.
They were tears of joy that I had finally made this happen and had met my first child.
And, yes, a small part of me was thinking of the son or daughter I didn’t get to meet.
And even though I am head over heels in love with my baby son, a little part of me probably always will think about that.
Peter Monaghan
2:54 pm on Monday, April 11, 2011
My wife and I too experienced the loss of a child during pregnancy, and my wife took every precaution and followed the doctors instructions to a T (We later learned that my wife needed to drink an obscene amount of water during pregnancy). I eventually came to realize that guilt is healthy and that it meant I was really ready to be a parent. I still carry that guilt today and I refuse to unburded myself by doing away with it.
David Greisman
3:25 pm on Monday, April 11, 2011
Dear Peter,
Thank you for your poignant, personal comment. I'm quite sorry for the loss that you and your wife experienced.
-David
Lisa Rossi
4:01 pm on Monday, April 11, 2011
Peter - so true! Guilt is a part of parenting - for both mothers AND fathers. I guess it's nature's way of keeping us at heightened awareness all the time. Thanks for sharing. - Lisa
Michelle
4:04 pm on Monday, April 11, 2011
Thank you for sharing Lisa. I experienced the same thing. I have a 10 month old daughter now, and I still think about what could have been...but what wasn't meant to happen.
Stephanie Walsh
9:03 pm on Friday, April 22, 2011
A study recently published in the medical literature reported that the emotional pain of miscarriage continues for many years longer than most doctors or others realized or acknowledged. Also, the myth that the birth of a healthy baby should or does erase the grief or loss of a previous miscarriage has been shown to be absolutely false.
Liz W
1:55 pm on Friday, May 20, 2011
Lisa, I am so grateful you took the time to share your experience on this topic. 6 years ago, I experienced a miscarriage with my second pregnancy. I found out I was pregnant, met with the doctor, and when I returned for my first ultrasound at 8 weeks, my baby had no heartbeat. I was taking a class during those weeks that caused a great deal of stress, had indigestion pretty much the whole time, and barely ate those 8 weeks due to nausea. Our son was 2 at the time, and we were sure we would have a full term pregnancy, as I had already withstood "the test" of birthing one. It was devastating news to bear. The hardest part was having to tell people for MONTHS (as we would run into people here and there) that we had lost the baby. I've since had a daughter, but couldn't enjoy my pregnancy with her. I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop. The pain seems to disappear and then some event will trigger the memory and bring it back as strong as if it had just happened. I know this has happened to others, but no one ever really talks about it. you have my gratitude for sharing such a personal event and making me feel more normal.