patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Chicken Pox and HPV? Both Should Be Vaccinated

The public debate on mandating HPV vaccines needs to center around facts about the level of public health risk cervical cancer poses.

 

I'm a carrier of a virus that rarely kills anyone on its own but is strongly corelated with a disease that affects millions of people. It's a disease that has been linked to serious developmental problems in children.

I was diagnosed during a routine test while I was pregnant with my daughter. They administered IV antibiotics to me during her delivery to prevent her from acquiring the virus.

Sounds dramatic, doesn't it? Happily, I am only talking about strep.

There are many forms of streptococcal infections. Some cause the strep throat we're all familiar with. Others cause skin rashes, notably on kids' bottoms. (Never mind how I know this.) Strep transmission in childbirth can cause infant blindness.

Strep is also tied to a condition called PANDAS (Pediatric Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorders Associated with Streptococcal Infections). The National Institutes of Mental Health describe the condition as "a subset of children who have Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) and/or tic disorders such as Tourette's Syndrome, and in whom symptoms worsen following strep infections such as 'Strep throat' and Scarlet Fever."

Who wouldn't want a vaccine to spare our kids that? Too bad there isn't one.

If you are in your 20's or older, you may remember your parents exposing you to kids with chicken pox so you could catch it too and get the itching and scabbing over with. Why? Well, chicken pox in childhood isn't all that dangerous for most. Chicken pox in adults can be deadly.

Once they developed a chicken pox vaccine, it was a few years before they made it mandatory in Maryland to attend public schools.

I'm curious to know how the number of women who die each year from cervical cancers adds up in comparison to the number of adults who die annually from chicken pox or shingles.

Now brace yourself for some TMI. That Group B streptococcus colony of mine? It does not live in my throat. It lives in my, ahem, birth canal.

It turns out not to be sexually transmitted. But honestly, until I looked it up on the internet to check just now, I'd kind of assumed it was. I mean, how on earth else would it have gotten there?

By the same token, not all Human Papillomavirus (HPV) infections are sexually transmitted or dangerous. But the ones that are sexually transmitted can lead to cancer.

All of my kids, boys and girl alike, are getting their HPV vaccines as they reach the appropriate age to do so.

The public debate on mandating HPV vaccines needs to center around facts about the level of public health risk cervical cancer poses. It shouldn't be about where individual viruses live in the human body or how they got there in the first place.

About this column: Kate Yemelyanov has three children – two sons, 14 and 11, and one daughter, 9 – plus a full-time job with one heck of a commute. She and her family live in Columbia in Owen Brown. "Mom On The Run" appears monthly on Columbia Patch. And you can also follow her at http://www.twitter.com/dinosaurmom or check out her blog, "Dinosaur Mom Chronicles," at http://www.dinosaurmom.com Related Topics: Childbirth, mandatory HPV vaccine, and streptococcal infections
Will you give your children an HPV vaccine? Tell us in the comments.

pandasparent

6:13 pm on Monday, September 19, 2011

What is up with this article? It doesn't make much sense. I realize it is a opinion piece, but the writer should probably educate herself better on the topics she brings up. She brings up PANDAS, so let's talk about PANDAS. What parent in their right mind would vaccinate their child with a strep vaccine in order to try to prevent that disorder from surfacing? It is an AUTOIMMUNE disorder in which the ANTIBODIES attack the brain, not strep itself. Vaccines STIMULATE the immune system and would cause those antibodies to be produced. Oh My Goodness!!! As a PANDAS parent, the sheer thought of doing that to my child on purpose makes me want to vomit! Please do not bring our suffering children into this unless you educate about the disorder. A strep vaccine will be here sooner than later and there is no way any of my children will ever get it.

Reply

Cynthia Wick

7:55 pm on Monday, September 19, 2011

Clearly researchers do not want to stimulate the development of PANDAS, and this may explain why there is not a vaccine for streptococcus yet. Presumably they have samples of the antibodies involved and will be careful that any vaccine developed would not create those particular antibodies.

However, that does not mean there will never be a vaccine for strep; there's the idea, for one, of creating a vaccine against just part of the streptococcus bacterium. This has been done in other cases and has allowed the human immune system to recognize and fight against those bacteria.

Thank you Kate for writing this opinion piece. Much of the brouhaha surrounding the HPV vaccine is due to parents being afraid of their children ever growing up and having sex, in my opinion. Without that fear, the risks & benefits can be assessed.

Reply

Shobha Krishnan

12:15 pm on Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Read more about the HPV vaccine controversy in the award winning book-The HPV Vaccine Controversy: Sex, Cancer, God and Politics

Reply

Leave a comment